The Failure Of Dark Universe

Sometimes the most spectacular failures are the ones that never actually happened. Universal’s Dark Universe—their audacious attempt to turn classic monsters into the next Marvel Cinematic Universe—died so quickly that most fans never realized how close we came to witnessing either a masterpiece or a magnificent disaster of unprecedented proportions.

That infamous 2017 cast photo wasn’t just marketing material—it was a prophecy written in Photoshop. The image featured Tom Cruise, Russell Crowe, Sofia Boutella, Johnny Depp, and Javier Bardem, but none of these A-listers were actually in the same room together. It was the perfect metaphor for a universe that existed only in spreadsheets and studio executives’ fever dreams.

• Johnny Depp’s Invisible Man would have been the franchise’s wildcard entry. Ed Solomon of Men in Black was set to pen the script, positioning the character within the shared universe. Imagine Depp’s eccentric energy channeled into a character who could literally disappear—the meta-commentary writes itself.

• Angelina Jolie’s Bride of Frankenstein represented the crown jewel of the franchise. Bill Condon signed on to direct with a Valentine’s Day 2019 release date, with the original script beginning in the 1870s and transitioning to the Bride re-awakening in the present day. This wasn’t just another monster movie—it was positioned as a feminist reimagining of one of cinema’s most iconic female characters.

• The Russell Crowe Strategy proved Universal understood the assignment from day one. Crowe’s Jekyll would likely have been the Dark Universe’s equivalent of Nick Fury, the man who would bring all disparate franchises together as the leader of Prodigium. Unlike Marvel’s gradual world-building, Universal was engineering their nexus character from the first film.

• Javier Bardem’s Frankenstein’s Monster would have anchored the franchise’s emotional core. Bardem was featured in the cast photo alongside the other leads, confirming his central role in the universe. The pairing with Jolie’s Bride promised a love story spanning centuries—Titanic with reanimated corpses.

More